Scott Beyer owns a 221-104 overall record, one NCAA Division III Championship World Series appearance, three national postseason trips, two regional titles, one Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference regular season championship, and one WIAC tournament title with the Titans. In Beyer's first ten seasons at the helm, UW-Oshkosh has established new school season records in batting average, doubles, triples, home runs, stolen bases, slugging percentage and fielding percentage.
Beyer, whose .680 winning percentage ranks fifth in WIAC history among coaches with at least 60 wins, has coached one All-American at UW-Oshkosh, 13 Titans to 22 total all-region honors and 20 players to 36 total all-conference awards, including 2015 WIAC Pitcher of the Year Sara Brunlieb, 2016 WIAC Co-Position Player of the Year Abby Menting and 2021 WIAC Pitcher of the Year Maddie Fink. Hannah Ritter in 2021 became the first UW-Oshkosh All-American selection since 2010. In 2014 a program record-tying five Titans received all-region accolades.